Treadwell, Machinal
A student asks, via e-mail:
I was wondering if you'd like the Machinal blogs in Act/Episode format or not, because I am sure you don't want the whole play in one entry.My reply:
I'm not asking you to write one agenda item per episode. If you have a lot to say about the play, you are, of course, welcome to write more than a single agenda item, or you can post a single longer-than-usual entry that includes several different quotations.
Categories: readings
29 Comments
Leave a comment
Recent Comments
Michelle Walters on Treadwell, Machinal: Can you relate Helen's personal struggles to your
Sue on Treadwell, Machinal: Machines are confusing http://blogs.setonhill.edu
Justin Iellimo on Treadwell, Machinal: young woman exclaims, "Life has been hell to me, F
Angela Saffer on Treadwell, Machinal: "YOUNG WOMAN. Tell me - (Words suddenly pouring ou
Justin Iellimo on Treadwell, Machinal: I find myself constantly questioning the character
Georgia Speer on Treadwell, Machinal: In reading the introduction of Machinal it struck
Dennis G. Jerz on Treadwell, Machinal: April found an excellent Machinal study guide, whi
Dennis G. Jerz on Treadwell, Machinal: Nikita says she thought the play was a confusing a
Jessica Bitar on Treadwell, Machinal: YOUNG WOMAN (reading). Prisoner escapes - lifer br
Nikita McClellan on Treadwell, Machinal: http://blogs.setonhill.edu/NikitaMcClellan/2009/02
Sue on Treadwell, Machinal: Machines are confusing http://blogs.setonhill.edu
Justin Iellimo on Treadwell, Machinal: young woman exclaims, "Life has been hell to me, F
Angela Saffer on Treadwell, Machinal: "YOUNG WOMAN. Tell me - (Words suddenly pouring ou
Justin Iellimo on Treadwell, Machinal: I find myself constantly questioning the character
Georgia Speer on Treadwell, Machinal: In reading the introduction of Machinal it struck
Dennis G. Jerz on Treadwell, Machinal: April found an excellent Machinal study guide, whi
Dennis G. Jerz on Treadwell, Machinal: Nikita says she thought the play was a confusing a
Jessica Bitar on Treadwell, Machinal: YOUNG WOMAN (reading). Prisoner escapes - lifer br
Nikita McClellan on Treadwell, Machinal: http://blogs.setonhill.edu/NikitaMcClellan/2009/02
Instructor
Class Roster
Andrew Adams
Julia Aughenbaugh
Julianne Banda
Sara Benaquista
Jessica Bitar
Chelsie Bitner
Rosalind Blair
Alicia Campbell
Stephanie Curley
Alura Defrancesco
Christopher Dufalla
Aja Hannah
Nathan Hart
Matthew Henderson
Annamarie Houston
Justin Iellimo
Quinn Kerno
Rebecca Marrie
Nikita McClellan
April Minerd
Sue Myers
Ashley Pascoe
Carlos Peredo
Jennifer Prex
Angela Saffer
Alyssa Sanow
Rachael Sarver
Georgia Speer
Marie VanMaanen
Michelle Walters
Joshua Wilks
Robert Zanni
Powered by
January
February
March
April
May
1 | 2 | |||||
3 | 04 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 |
10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 |
17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 |
24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 |
31 |
"You look so silly - oh I know what's coming when you look like that - and kiss me like that - don't - go - away - "(Treadwell 18).
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/JulianneBanda/2009/02/offstage_importance.html
Stones - stones - small stones
Foreshadowing the Young Woman doing away with her husbands life
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/JoshuaWilks/2009/02/love_and_money.html
Whoops...
"Love - what does that amount too! Will it clothe you? Will it feed you? Will it pay the bills?" pg 17
"YOUNG WOMAN. Where do we go from here?
SECOND MAN. Where do we go from here! You just got here!
FIRST MAN. What's the hurry?
SECOND MAN. What's the rush?
YOUNG WOMAN. I don't know."
~page 35 in Episode 5
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/JenniferPrex/2009/02/always_on_the_go.html
HUSBAND (pulling her back to his knee). No, I didn’t! Not by jugful! I got a lot of ‘em up my sleeve yet – that’s part of what I owe my success to – my ability to spring a good story – You know – you got to relax, little girl – haven’t you?
(Treadwell 23-24)
Treadwell’s Machinal addresses many social issues that plagued American society during the late 1920’s. The foremost would be the position of women during this period; it was a time inflamed with the suffragette movement, with women demanding equality. In Machinal the husband is referred to in the script as “HUSBAND” while the man’s wife is referred to as “YOUNG WOMAN,” not “WIFE.”
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/AlyssaSanow/2009/02/murderess_or_victim.html
NURSE (to young woman) "Aren't you glad it's a girl? You're not! Oh my! That's no way to talk! Men want boys - women ought to want girls."
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/AliciaCampbell/2009/02/youre_having_a_girlcongratulat.html
Hot dog?? Does anyone know what that means? Give me some of your ideas.
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/NathanHart/2009/02/hot_dog.html
"FIRST REPORTER. Suppose the machine shouldn't work!
SECOND REPORTER. It'll work! - It always works!"
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/MatthewHenderson/2009/02/the_machine_doesnt_stop.html
What actually happened? We'll never know.
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/RebeccaMarrie/2009/02/what_actually_happened_well_ne.html
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/RosalindBlair/2009/02/love_again.html
"MOTHER: In love! Is that beginning again! I thought you were over that!" – Machinal Episode Two p.15
Boy, as I started reading this play I thought a feminist had finally come along that had earned my sympathy.
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/CarlosPeredo/2009/02/feminism_i_like_nope_i_was_wro.html
"Love! -what does that amount to! Will it clothe you? Will it feed you? Will it pay the bills?"
Treadwell, page 17 (the mother)
How useful is love?
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/ChristopherDufalla/2009/02/money_practical_love_impractic.html
PITIFUL: "you just take it for granted - you'd let me go on forever - and never feel any pity"
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/AprilMinerd/2009/02/cant_find_sympathy.html
"-God never had one - Mary had one"
Is the young woman comparing herself to the Virgin Mary?
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/MarieVanMaanen/2009/02/young_woman_gets_biblical.html
Nameless Abortions - The lack of names and a secret baby?
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/AjaHannah/2009/02/nameless_abortions.html
"YOUNG WOMAN. I've been free father, for one moment, down here on earth, I have been free. When I did what I did, I was free. Free, and not afraid. How is that, Father? How can that be? I great sin, a mortal sin, for which I must die and go to hell, but it made me free! One moment, I was free then, how is that Father? Tell me that." Treadwell, page 80
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/SaraBenaquista/2009/02/life_is_a_machine.html
Hot Dog!
The use of repetition and its sing-song quality
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/AndrewAdams/2009/02/hot_dog.html
Leave it to a PA major to try and diagnose this chick...
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/RachaelSarver/2009/02/starting_to_crack.html
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/NikitaMcClellan/2009/02/no_sympathy_here.html
I dont have sympathy for helen
YOUNG WOMAN (reading). Prisoner escapes - lifer breaks jail - shoots way to freedom - (pg 55)
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/JessicaBitar/2009/02/freedom.html
Nikita says she thought the play was a confusing and a bit boring... I posted a response that pointed out we're reading the script, which is just a blueprint to the whole performance. I mentioned a few scenes that will require some imagination and careful reading of the stage directions, before we can really see what kind of an emotional effect they might have.
April found an excellent Machinal study guide, which introduces Treadwell and her times (this is the end of the 20s... before the Great Depression, so the economic boom was still going on, but more artists had joined the likes of Fitzgerald in criticizing the culture of mindless work that we see in offices).
In reading the introduction of Machinal it struck me that Treadwell is associating the nine scenes with the nine months of gestation for a women. I know that I don't think that I would have put those two things together, however since she points this out it was quite interesting to connect the two.
I find myself constantly questioning the character of this young woman..... On page 29, a Nurse says, "You got a mighty nice husband, I guess you know that?"
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/JustinIellimo/2009/02/shes_in_it_for_the_money.html
"YOUNG WOMAN. Tell me - (Words suddenly pouring out.)
Your skin oughtn't to curl - ought it - when he just comes near you - ought it? That's wrong, ain't it? You don't get over that, do you - ever, do you or do you? How is it, Ma - do you?
MOTHER. Do you what?
YOUNG WOMAN. Do you get used to, it - so after a while it doesn't matter? Or don't you? Does it always matter? You ought to be in love, oughtn't you, Ma? You must be in love, musn't you, Ma? That changes everything, doesn't it - or does it? Maybe if you just like a person it's all right - isn't it? When he puts a hand on me, my blood turns cold. But your blood oughtn't to run cold, ought it?..."
young woman exclaims, "Life has been hell to me, Father!" The young woman seems to have no regrets about murdering her husband.
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/JustinIellimo/2009/02/life_has_been_hell_to_me.html
Machines are confusing
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/SueMyers/2009/02/sometimes-machi.html
Can you relate Helen's personal struggles to your own life?