A journalism student at NYU published a Generation Y-ney piece on PBS’s MediaShift.
The first thing I notice when I walk into the class is that there are 14 girls and two boys. Already NYU is dominated by females, but the journalism department is exceptionally estrogen-infested. Professor Quigley begins by explaining how blogs are becoming more imprtant and asks if any of us have a blog.
One hand slowly rises. It’s mine. (Alana Taylor)
It’s certainly… interesting to have a student publicly evaluate a class in this manner, after the class has been in session for a few weeks. While she is careful to distance her essay from a personal attack on her professor, she complains about the old-media stance of the course, and the program as a whole. Based on the scarcity of student bloggers in this particular classroom, it seems to me that the professor is pitching the class at the right level — though the generic term “blog” is far less familiar to today’s teens than branded bloglike entities ”Facebook” or “MySpace.”
My former student, Amanda Cochran, now a grad student at NYU, reacts to Taylor’s piece.
Like Taylor, I am one of the only bloggers in my graduate school class, and I’m looked upon as a novelty. As many of my readers know, blogging was an important part of my undergrad experience. We were on the cutting edge of journalism (and still are) at Seton Hill — as it would seem in light of this report. I know about blogging. I know what I need to do to write a good blog. This ability has enhanced my resume and, more importantly, my understanding of online media and its direction. However, it is true that few other students do know about blogging and its ramifications on their future careers.
Okay, so Taylor made a point. So what? She has done much more harm than good to her career by this stunt. Taylor, looking oh-so-Facebookish in the picture posted with the piece, did invade her classroom, as cited by NYU professor Quigley. However, more importantly, no matter if she isn’t a traditional journalist or not, she violated a journalistic tenet of disclosure to her subjects for a completely unworthy assignment. If I were an employer, I would think twice before hiring her — and that’s enough in this competitive business to stay unemployed. (Amanda Cochran)
Taylor had planned to write a follow-up for MediaShift, but editor Mark Glaser did so instead.