Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary: Origin
Mary Mary quite contrary,I found this on Circant, where I left the following comment:
How does your garden grow?
With silver bells and cockle shells
And pretty maids all in a row.The origins are steeped in history...
The Mary alluded to in this traditional English nursery rhyme is Mary Tudor, or Bloody Mary, who was the daughter of King Henry VIII. Queen Mary was a staunch Catholic and the garden referred to is an allusion to graveyards which were increasing in size with those who dared to continue to adhere to the Protestant faith. The silver bells and cockle shells were colloquialisms for instruments of torture. The 'maids' were a device to behead people similar to the guillotine. --Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary: Origin (Rhymes)
The Mary Tudor suggestion sounds like it affirms the adage that history is written by the winners. The history of Protestantism in England wasn't very long during the reign of Henry VIII's daughter, and thus the phrasing "dared to continue to adhere to the Protestant faith" sounds very biased. Henry VIII burned plenty of Lutherans in his day; Microsoft's Encarta characterizes Henry VIII's reforms as chiefly political rather than theological.http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761562628_2/Reformation.html.
Here's a website with several additional interpretations of the rhyme.
4 Comments
Leave a comment
Recent Related Entries
Collaborative Authorship Made EasyA good overview of the issues relating to using Wikis in the classroom. From the NCTE Inbox Blog:The benefits for collaborative writing should be obvious. Wikis allow multiple authors to edit a text easily. While the video doesn't discuss it,...
Does anybody remember that Facebook thing?
A group of Seton Hill graduates who bonded through the SHU blogosphere in 2003 and 2004 have continued to use their blogs, and there are some newer students who have made an effort to continue their blogging this summer. Since...
Go Ahead, Steal My Car
The Chronicle Review ponders the effects of Grand Theft Auto IV:You need to be honest with yourself. Go outside and find a locked car -- or go to the back alley where missile launchers hover in a glowing light waiting for...
Above the Law?
Inside Higher Ed:Student newspaper advisers are something of an endangered species these days. They often get caught in the middle when administrators and student journalists clash over content, and in more than a few cases on college campuses in recent...
Using Text Analysis Tools for Comparison: Mole & Chocolate Cake « Digital Scholarship in the Humanities
Lisa Spiro posts an interesting analysis:I wanted to get a quick visual sense of the two texts, so I plugged them into Wordle, a nifty word cloud generator that enables you to control variables such as layout, font and color....
"Mary, Mary, quite contrary (kind to children, nasty to everyone else) How does your garden grow? (insult that Mary's children died in her womb) With silver bells, (insult that she was too ugly to bed.) And cockle shells, (Philip II had many affairs, cheating on your wife was called "cockertelling".) And pretty maids all in a row.." (Mary's babies who died prematurely.)
Thanks, PH, for that explication. Is "cockertelling" related to "cuckolding"? I hadn't heard that one before.
Hey, This is the story I have heard for Mary, Mary Quite Contrart:
Back in the day, Queen Mary (dont know which one) was starting to to grow old, and it was getting time to have her successor take over. Mary didnt want to give up power, so every woman that would and could have been a successor and taken over, she killed and buried them in her garden and planted silver bells and cockle shells over.
Thanks,
BROOKE
That's a very interesting possibility... thanks, BROOKE.