Slap in the Facebook: It's Time for Social Networks to Open Up
Like locked cell phones and copy-protected music, Facebook is on the wrong side of the open-network debate. Facebook is a sealed bubble. Facebook users are locked into Facebook, just as iTunes locks music fans to Apple's iPod.I couldn't have said it better. This is why I have no particular desire to use a fenced-in system. Yes, I have my students blog with MovableType, but the software is free for private users.
This serves companies' business interests, but not the wider interests of consumers.
[...]
At this point, "friend" relationships remain unique to the social networks. The web still lacks a generalized way to convey relationships between people's identities on the internet. The absence of this secret sauce -- an underlying framework that connects "friends" and establishes trust relationships between peers -- is what gave rise to social networks in the first place. --Scott Gilbertson --Slap in the Facebook: It's Time for Social Networks to Open Up (Wired)
Having said that, I realize that the appeal for some people is precisely that they can share their information with a small group of friends, but all it takes is for one friend to squeal.
I also confess to feeling a bit uncomfortable at the prospect of contacting a researcher whose work I find useful, and telling them I want to be his or her "friend". In the clinically hierarchical world of academia, even "colleague" might be presumptuous.
3 Comments
Leave a comment
Recent Related Entries
Famous Programmers From Adleman to ZimmermannLook who's up there with Ada Lovelace and Grace Hopper:Famous women programmers are Adele Goldberg, who worked at Xerox PARC laboratory and wrote a number of SmallTalk books, Grace Hopper, a pioneer in the field who wrote the first compiler,...
Immune Attack
Federation of American Scientists (FAS) makes a First-Person Shooter (FPS). Whoever wrote the description of the game won't get a job at PC Gamer anytime soon, but the game itself looks interesting.Players navigate a nanobot through a 3D environment of...
The End of Theory: The Data Deluge Makes the Scientific Method Obsolete
Wired:The Petabyte Age is different because more is different. Kilobytes were stored on floppy disks. Megabytes were stored on hard disks. Terabytes were stored in disk arrays. Petabytes are stored in the cloud. As we moved along that progression, we...
Inside Google Book Search: U.S. copyright renewal records available for download
Inside Google Book SearchFor U.S. books published between 1923 and 1963, the rights holder needed to submit a form to the U.S. Copyright Office renewing the copyright 28 years after publication. In most cases, books that were never renewed are...
Collaborative Authorship Made Easy
A good overview of the issues relating to using Wikis in the classroom. From the NCTE Inbox Blog:The benefits for collaborative writing should be obvious. Wikis allow multiple authors to edit a text easily. While the video doesn't discuss it,...
Fascinating how the term "friend" has morphed since the genesis of social networking... We don't just "make friends" anymore--we must "be friended" or "added as a friend" to have our names displayed alongside others with whom a person associates (or knows vaguely through minor interaction). Rejection is a lot easier, too, in that sense. If someone requests to be my friend I can deny the request--try doing this face-to-face. I can't honestly say that I could. I would at least speak kindly to the person instead of handing them a conclusive (and unannounced) rejection--on Facebook you never know if someone has accepted or rejected the request. I have some friends (real-life friends, mind you) who choose to weed out their friend lists once in awhile to keep a true-to-life list of friends. I have to admit, it makes things a lot less creepy when you actually do know the folks whose "Wall" you're writing on to say "Happy Birthday!" or "I love your profile pic."
I've also heard the verb form "to friend" (meaning "to add as a friend"). Some time ago I came across the term "friends cut," which emphasizes the capitalization of social status.
I think they've added a "Top Friends" option to Facebook to kind of address this "need" to distinguish friends you simply added at the beginning of Facebook and those that you really like now. It's amazing how Facebook keeps evolving. Software is made specifically for the community. Sleek advertising is added surreptiously to "help" students with their back-to-school transitions. And if it makes kids feel like their within their own bubble, they're keeping it exclusive, but only to the point so that it serves their marketing purposes. Genius. If I'd start an entrepreneurial group, I know who I'd invite first: Facebook creators. I wonder if they'd be my friends? haha