CCCC 2008
The Conference on College Composition and Communication is the big annual meeting of college writing instructors. One often encounters technical writing instructors, social scientists, ethnographers, and new media innovators (we had Larry Lessig give a featured address a few years ago), as well as traditional essayists and grammar mavens. It's the kind of place where someone can say, "That reminds me of Aristotle's five canons of rhetoric... inventio, dispositio, elocutio, actio, and... uh.. .what's the other one?" and it's likely that the others will get the joke.
While walking around the city after the conference was over, I had a vision of a future 4Cs conference that made me giddy. I'll tell you about it in a little bit. First, let me talk about the conference.
While walking around the city after the conference was over, I had a vision of a future 4Cs conference that made me giddy. I'll tell you about it in a little bit. First, let me talk about the conference.
Some 3,400 attendees came to New Orleans. In the past I have brought my
laptop, taken furious notes all day long, and blogged them at night. I
didn't do that this time, in part because I was lazy and I didn't want
to carry my laptop on the one-mile walk from my hotel (on the site of
an old opera house, in Bourbon Street, in the heart of the French
Quarter). Also, the battery on my laptop is dying, so that I'm getting
less than an hour from each chge, and I didn't want to have to be
sitting in the back near where the plugs are.
This year, there were not as many panels on weblogs, and more on video games and 3D shared spaces such as Second Life. As much as I love games and 3D spaces, I've yet to find a good articulation of why and/or how games can make students write better paragraphs. Yes, students can write paragraphs about games, or they can use games as inspirations to write traditional genres such as character studies or travel literature, and yes games can be useful to simulate experiences such as conflicts or emergencies that students might write about. I use games to introduce English majors to programming (in two different courses, one at a very basic and another at a more advanced level), and the different audiences for a new media artifact (that is, they must write text and design an interface for the end user; code for the computer; and comments for other programmers).
There were many panels on new media, or multimedia, or multimodality (all of which mean pretty much the same thing, and I won't bore you with the shades of meaning).
I've got stacks of papers to mark and there is usually a huge pile of dishes for me to wash when I get home. (I've been married 14 years and my wife does not know how to use the dishwasher... I'm actually kind of proud of that.) So I'm not sure how many panels I'll actually write about.
But I will note that the town meeting (at 8 this morning) was very enjoyable. The very small number of members (as I understand it, out of the 3400 at the conference, 75 is considered a quorum at the business meeting) immediately passed a resolution in favor of supporting open-source software. (Charlie Lowe, who was a driving force behind that resolution, already had reason to feel happy because he spent $5 at a casino and ended up winning $1200.)
Then we did small group discussions, choosing one of five questions. I picked a question about how the 4Cs experience might change in the next 5 or 15 years, given changes in the students we teach and the technology we use. The first comments at my table were about the digital divide; while most of us seemed to feel the divide was getting less serious, others reminded us that they teach in schools where they still can't expect students to have access to computers, and where the schools don't provide enough computer lab spaces.
In way, most of the 4Cs members got a taste of the digital divide, since the Hilton does not offer free Wi-Fi. Some individuals sprang for something like $15 for wireless access, but I went to numerous sessions where presenters just assumed they'd be able to show websites or YouTube clips during their presentations. It was extremely frustrating to be cut off from or students while we were at the conference, but even more frustrating to me was the fact that we were cut off from each other.
I asked why the 4Cs wasn't encouraging liveblogging. We have some featured sessions with hundreds of attendees. If we webcasted at least the featured presentations, and encouraged liveblogging by setting up WiFi hotspots, and set up a system to encourage individual panels to upload audio from their sessions, just think of all the peer-to-peer knowledge we could be constructing, all the feedback we could be providing to presenters, and all the information we could be communicating to our colleagues who could not attend, and to teachers of English around the world.
Janice Walker and Michael Day were the executive committee members who were doing the note-taking. They were both all for WiFi. Janice said the contracts with the hotels are negotiated years in advance, but that the Hilton contract would be up for re-negotiation soon. Let's keep our fingers crossed. I said I'd be willing to check a box to pay a little extra money to have WiFi access throughout the conference. So let's keep our fingers crossed.
As I was walking around the French Quarter and the Riverwalk, I suddenly had a vision of a log-in screen that would deliver a stream of updates from those who are blogging (or Twittering) the conference.
What if we set up a system where bloggers could claim various sessions, and register their blogs with a central RSS feed. The bloggers would tag their blog entries with the session ID (D16 or L24 or whatever) and each time CCCC members log into the CCCC-provided WiFi account, they see a welcome screen that says what session is currently under way, and an aggregator showing who is blogging about the current session. Each session could have its own bulletin board, so that if you realize you're in one of those depressing sessions where the speakers fill up the entire time so that there's no time left over for questions, the audience members can still have their say. After the session, presenters could post links to their slideshows, websites, or the text of their papers.
It's not at all uncommon for the best things to come out of a conference to be the "aha!" moments that happen in the hallways, between sessions, when we discuss with our colleagues what we've just seen. As a profession, we're aware that our teaching methods need to change in order to account for the hypercognition that characterizes the way our students experience the world -- through social networking, digital multitasking, and and endless process of self-creation through remixing. We can learn about their world by experiencing it for ourselves.
This year, there were not as many panels on weblogs, and more on video games and 3D shared spaces such as Second Life. As much as I love games and 3D spaces, I've yet to find a good articulation of why and/or how games can make students write better paragraphs. Yes, students can write paragraphs about games, or they can use games as inspirations to write traditional genres such as character studies or travel literature, and yes games can be useful to simulate experiences such as conflicts or emergencies that students might write about. I use games to introduce English majors to programming (in two different courses, one at a very basic and another at a more advanced level), and the different audiences for a new media artifact (that is, they must write text and design an interface for the end user; code for the computer; and comments for other programmers).
There were many panels on new media, or multimedia, or multimodality (all of which mean pretty much the same thing, and I won't bore you with the shades of meaning).
I've got stacks of papers to mark and there is usually a huge pile of dishes for me to wash when I get home. (I've been married 14 years and my wife does not know how to use the dishwasher... I'm actually kind of proud of that.) So I'm not sure how many panels I'll actually write about.
But I will note that the town meeting (at 8 this morning) was very enjoyable. The very small number of members (as I understand it, out of the 3400 at the conference, 75 is considered a quorum at the business meeting) immediately passed a resolution in favor of supporting open-source software. (Charlie Lowe, who was a driving force behind that resolution, already had reason to feel happy because he spent $5 at a casino and ended up winning $1200.)
Then we did small group discussions, choosing one of five questions. I picked a question about how the 4Cs experience might change in the next 5 or 15 years, given changes in the students we teach and the technology we use. The first comments at my table were about the digital divide; while most of us seemed to feel the divide was getting less serious, others reminded us that they teach in schools where they still can't expect students to have access to computers, and where the schools don't provide enough computer lab spaces.
In way, most of the 4Cs members got a taste of the digital divide, since the Hilton does not offer free Wi-Fi. Some individuals sprang for something like $15 for wireless access, but I went to numerous sessions where presenters just assumed they'd be able to show websites or YouTube clips during their presentations. It was extremely frustrating to be cut off from or students while we were at the conference, but even more frustrating to me was the fact that we were cut off from each other.
I asked why the 4Cs wasn't encouraging liveblogging. We have some featured sessions with hundreds of attendees. If we webcasted at least the featured presentations, and encouraged liveblogging by setting up WiFi hotspots, and set up a system to encourage individual panels to upload audio from their sessions, just think of all the peer-to-peer knowledge we could be constructing, all the feedback we could be providing to presenters, and all the information we could be communicating to our colleagues who could not attend, and to teachers of English around the world.
Janice Walker and Michael Day were the executive committee members who were doing the note-taking. They were both all for WiFi. Janice said the contracts with the hotels are negotiated years in advance, but that the Hilton contract would be up for re-negotiation soon. Let's keep our fingers crossed. I said I'd be willing to check a box to pay a little extra money to have WiFi access throughout the conference. So let's keep our fingers crossed.
As I was walking around the French Quarter and the Riverwalk, I suddenly had a vision of a log-in screen that would deliver a stream of updates from those who are blogging (or Twittering) the conference.
What if we set up a system where bloggers could claim various sessions, and register their blogs with a central RSS feed. The bloggers would tag their blog entries with the session ID (D16 or L24 or whatever) and each time CCCC members log into the CCCC-provided WiFi account, they see a welcome screen that says what session is currently under way, and an aggregator showing who is blogging about the current session. Each session could have its own bulletin board, so that if you realize you're in one of those depressing sessions where the speakers fill up the entire time so that there's no time left over for questions, the audience members can still have their say. After the session, presenters could post links to their slideshows, websites, or the text of their papers.
It's not at all uncommon for the best things to come out of a conference to be the "aha!" moments that happen in the hallways, between sessions, when we discuss with our colleagues what we've just seen. As a profession, we're aware that our teaching methods need to change in order to account for the hypercognition that characterizes the way our students experience the world -- through social networking, digital multitasking, and and endless process of self-creation through remixing. We can learn about their world by experiencing it for ourselves.
8 Comments
Leave a comment
Recent Related Entries
At M.I.T., Large Lectures Are Going the Way of the BlackboardAt M.I.T., two introductory courses are still required -- classical mechanics and electromagnetism -- but today they meet in high-tech classrooms, where about 80 students sit at 13 round tables equipped with networked computers.Instead of blackboards, the walls are covered...
Humanities Resource Center Online
The American Academy of Arts and Sciences has released a major study that aims to establish benchmarks for assessing the humanities. Assessment was one of the major issues that arose during last year's English program review, so this is worth...
Proving the Benefits of Peer Instruction
Another article that's on my mind as I consider how to integrate group work into an unusually large literature class. In an undergraduate genetics course, students were, on 16 occasions during the course of a semester, asked a pair of...
Risks of Admissions Marketing on Facebook
Admissions officers are looking for the "silver bullet" to uncover the secret to social networking. But, as this latest controversy illustrates, there is no magic solution in a space whose content is controlled by users, and policed by a community....
10 Things about the Working World I Wish I Knew in College
Let's face it--each new stage in life brings dramatic changes that are difficult to anticipate. No matter how smart you can be in college, you will still get surprised by the working world.I faced these surprises myself. I thought the...

Great con report. Sounds like you had a renewing and reflective experience and that you saw some really great panels (and anyone who goes to an 8am panel voluntarily is amazing, I think... just look at those 75 out of 3400 odds...that's likd 2% attendance, and even that is pretty high). Looking forward to hearing more about how yours went.
That youtube is kind of funny in a 'profs gone wild' sort of way.
Thank you for sharing the video! I was not at the opening session but had I been I would have led the second line!
Also, thanks for summarizing the ideas for wifi at future conferences. I'm about to blog about all the things I would have liked to include in my hurried session, so I will definitely link here for support for my argument!
Oh one more thing. I checked on the "AV session" email I received and it looks like even with the wired internet connection they promised, the room details stated, "There will be NO Audio connection for computer you can get this for a charge."
So much for sharing anything beyond text! Multi-modal nothing!
Okay, thanks for that point, Daisy. Michael Day and Janice Walker were the CCCC executive committee members at my table... you might want to relay your concerns to them, too.
I'm going to link to her on my blog but you may want to read Dawn's issues with the lack of internet on that Saturday http://girl-inchoate.com/2008/4cs-recap/
Thanks for the suggestion, Daisy. I tried to post a brief comment on her blog, but something about my content or my ISP triggered her spam blocker and when I hit the go back button, my message was gone so I couldn't even e-mail it to her. Oh, well.
Actually she does get the comment. It happens the 1st time you post...something with her WordPress. I'll twitter her to make sure, esp since I'm recruiting her for next year's SIG!
Great. Any interest in participating in a workshop on instructional technology?