Heading East: Lies I've told my 3 year old recently

Yesterday was my daughter's sixth birthday. My wife told me that there was a horrific meltdown at the store when the ice cream cake they picked up did not match the picture in the catalog.  Screams, tears, and a half hour of sobbing.

Last night, I told my daughter the story of The Birthday Party of Smart Carolyn from the Moon (Smart Carolyn is the character my daughter identifies with in the Captain Rod Gearhart steampunk stories I tell her at bedtime).  Smart Carolyn was disappointed that her Moon birthday cake wasn't what she expected, and had a temper tantrum in the Moon supply depot.  I told her about the Moon supply clerk who had traveled to five different supply posts searching for the right color frosting, and who felt very, very sad that Smart Carolyn from the Moon didn't even say thank you. 

My daughter sniffled a little in the dark, and then she continued the story for me: "And then Smart Carolyn from the Moon got over it, and realized that the store clerk had tried her best, and that's what was really important. And the cake was delicious."

So this morning I was in a pensive mood when I came across this blog, "Lies I've told my 3 year old recently."

Everyone knows at least one secret language.

When nobody is looking, I can fly.

We are all held together by invisible threads.

Books get lonely too.

Sadness can be eaten.

The very last one on the list is the reason I blogged it. But I didn't include it here... go read it over on Heading East.

7 Comments

Sadly, all of the rhetoric lies with its title using the word "lies" and that last line, which drastically changes the blog post's pedagogical possibilities. If the blog post did not use "lies" in its title and did not include the last line, then it might be helpful for teaching readers about the value of imagination.

This made me cry.

It was a good cry. Thanks for this.

It is a cruel reminder of our mortality. As a parent I hope this is a lie, I would hate to outlive my son.

This happened to me before too.
Poor little Carolyn.

Bobby, I think the entry is still useful to teach about both rhetoric and creativity... the author created a mood, and then used it skillfully to zig-zag emotionally, creating a contrast that really drives a point home (as Stormy and Mitchell agreed).

Yes, Chelsea, sometimes I still have days like this, only I just do it quietly, in between appointments, in my office with my door closed. If my colleagues notice, they don't talk about it.

Eric Glicker said:

Happy Birthday to your daughter. Hope she had a nice party together with her family and friends. It's my birthday tomorrow on the 14th. I posted that I'd lead with Daisy at the conference next year. Looking forward to working on that bibliography. I'll be in Indiana from July to December if you want to chat sometime.

Eric, happy birthday (early). Glad to hear you've agreed to lead the SIG. I'll be happy to help you with the proposal, if you like. Yes, let's keep the bibliography project in mind. I'd love to meet up with you during your stay in the area.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Recent Related Entries

Sibling Affection and Paternal Abstraction as Drawn By a Six-Year-Old; or, Aren't My Daughter's Drawings Cute?
My six-year-old daughter is a very visual thinker, who absolutely adores her brother. About a year ago, I stumbled across a notebook of sketches I made in 1980, when I was 12, and I remember how much I enjoyed drawing...

Does anybody remember that Facebook thing?
A group of Seton Hill graduates who bonded through the SHU blogosphere in 2003 and 2004 have continued to use their blogs, and there are some newer students who have made an effort to continue their blogging this summer. Since...

Dad-the-Geek and His Hardware Hijinks
At night, no one can hear you do a happy dance. And I must stifle my victory whoops, so as not to wake up the rest of the family.  But I can still pronounce my geeky successes through my blog....

Oh, the Irony
My kids are playing on the floor as I carry out my online routine. Carolyn is mixing and matching from different Lego sets in order to create characters from the "Magnificent Blimpship" steampunk bedtime stories I've been telling her.She aims...

Seeing the International Space Station
I just took the kids outside to watch the International Space Station fly overhead. It was visible for about five minutes, and at its brightest I thought I could see some details (the solar panels?), but it was mostly just...