Is Wikipedia Becoming a Respectable Academic Source?

Posted by Dennis G. Jerz on September 1, 2008 9:55 AM | | Comments (0) ~
Last year a colleague in the English department described a conversation in which a friend revealed a dirty little secret: "I use Wikipedia all the time for my research--but I certainly wouldn't cite it."  This got me wondering: How many humanities and social sciences researchers are discussing, using, and citing Wikipedia? -- Lisa Spiro
When the subject is pop culture, political rumors, new internet trends, or if the author is clearly citing something way out of his or her subject domain (such as an engineer citing the literary origin of the term "robot" or a humanist explaining a geek joke) then I would prefer that the body of the paper identify that the source is Wikipedia, in which case I would register the link, absorb the fact that the author has just signaled that this point is simply explanatory and not crucial to the main argument, and I would move on.

But if a growing number of academics are using Wikipedia in their published scholarly work, then the "No Wikipedia, Ever!!" mindset requires re-examination.


Categories: Academia , Cyberculture , Education , Humanities , Literacy , Media , Philosophy , Rhetoric , Social_Software , Technology

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Search

Recent Related Entries

Job Opening: Interactive & Assistive Technology Specialist at Seton Hill University [ISTE Career Center]
Seton Hill recently won a multimillion dollar instruction technology grant, part of which includes funding for a new technology specialist (which will become a permanent job when the grant ends).  In helping to write the job notice, I drafted the...

good lord.....I finally see the light.
My student Dani Choynowski, a double-major in new media journalism and theatre, is a very busy woman.  She's getting top-notch grades in two challenging majors, her hand is usually the first one up during workshops or discussions, and she's always...

At NYU, the Only Blogger In Her Generation Y Class Vents
A journalism student at NYU published a Generation Y-ney piece on PBS's MediaShift. The first thing I notice when I walk into the class is that there are 14 girls and two boys. Already NYU is dominated by females, but...

Kids spread cheating methods on YouTube
'Hi YouTube, it's me, Kiki,'' the teenager said to the camera as she swiveled in her chair to jazzy background music. ''And today I'm going to show you how to cheat on a test - the effective way.'' She demonstrates...

Courthouse News Service
Via Crooked Timber and BoingBoing:Thomson Reuters demands $10 million and an injunction to stop George Mason University from distributing its new Web browser application, Zotero software, an open-source format that allows users to convert Reuters' EndNote Software. Reuters claims George...