January 14, 2010 Archives
Let's revisit our understanding of key concepts, as we move into the final unit (which is designed to help you develop your term project).
Based on class interest, in this slot, I'm going to name:
Mutual Fantasy Online: Playing with People (Mortensen)
Torill actually visited SHU several years ago, when academic blogging -- and blogging in general -- was very new. I invited her to present on media panics and hypertext theory.
The story of how I spent a week getting a group of students to disagree with what she was posting on her blog, then asking them to consider what they would say to her if they ever met her, and then having her walk into the classroom was quite amusing.
Discussion leaders: Beth Anne and Jeremy.
Choose any video game, classic or new, on any platform, and present a case study. Explain why your choice is worthy of academic study. Offer supporting materials and discussion questions.
- As with Portfolio 1, please post a link to Porftolio 2 by 4pm, even if your portfolio isn't quite finished.
- For all the presubmissions that are in on time tomorrow, I aim to provide quick feedback (within a few hours, I hope).
- There is no homework assigned for Monday, due to the holiday. I will, however, be checking in over the weekend, to guide you as you continue to develop your ideas for the research project.
Every time I introduce a research paper assignment, some students attempt to fall back on a strategy that worked for them in high school. They write up the whole paper based on what they already think about their chosen topic, and then they "look for quotes" from sources that agree with them.
But that's not research -- that's just seeking conformation of your own biases. If you've invested time in writing up a paper based on what you already think, human nature will lead to ignore the very sources you can learn the most from -- the sources that challenge what you think you know.
Equipping the Right Thesis
Although the subject of the course is "games" and a central question is "what is fun?", there's no avoiding the fact that writing a college research paper on any subject is an intellectually demanding task.
In high school, you probably never had to struggle to find a thesis, possibly because you were given a statement and told to agree or disagree, or you were given a list of thesis statements to choose from. If that's the case, you might be worried that you're doing something wrong. You might feel that if only you were a little smarter or the course weren't so intense, you would know what you were supposed to be writing about.
You might be a little frustrated by the research task you face. You might be tempted to fall back on that strategy that worked in high school -- write the paper first, based on your own opinions, and then "look for quotes" later.
What makes the research process in our class especially difficult is the abundance of online information written in a snappy, appealing manner. It's hard to turn your attention away from the low-hanging fruit -- the popular articles and fansites (that are designed to be almost as "fun" as the games they cover) -- and turn your attention towards academic research (which still makes my head hurt from time to time -- especially after a satisfying session of Onslaught 2).
The Research Process in a Nutshell
- Choose a general topic.
- Look for credible sources.
- Keep looking, until you
- come up with a thesis based on the materials you've found, or
- change your topic to better match the kinds of information you can actually find.
Please let me know how you feel, and how I can help you on this journey.