Paper and pencil, not computer, boosts creativity
In a Ph.D. thesis called “The Paradox of the Guided User,” a dutch researcher examined the productivity of users who were dependent on computers, and users who had a pen-and-paper alternative. The article doesn’t link to the full dissertation, so it’s risky to extrapolate beyond the quotes in the article, so I’ll just repeat a few here:
“Present-day software must be user-friendly. Indeed, train ticket
machines at railway stations should be simple and provide us with a
ticket quickly,” van Nimwegen told Deutsche Presse-Agentur dpa.“But in other situations, I think we should not be assisted as much
as graphic software interfaces like Microsoft Windows or Apple OSX are
doing today,” he added.Van Nimwegen says much software turns us into passive beings,
subjected to the whims of computers, randomly clicking on icons and
menu options. In the long run, this hinders our creativity and memory,
he says. —eNews 2.0
This article meshes nicely with a unit I’m preparing to spring on my Writing for the Internet students later this week. I’m trying to get them past the “creative hypertext is confusing and boring” attitude that sometimes prevents experienced ‘net users from appreciating the hyperauthor’s use of a medium that can, in fact, be disorienting and alienating.
Next, I’m going to introduce them to the command line, in order to prepare my English majors to appreciate the lesson I’m trying to teach them when I ask them to do some elementary programming and game-creation tasks.
Similar:
Google’s healthcare AI made up a body part — what happens when doctors don’t notice?
Study finds AI tools made open source software developers 19 percent slower
I MacGyvered myself a heat sink
Unemployment rates for recent college grads: Overall, 5.8%; Computer science, 6.1%; Comput...
Waiting for a talk on preserving artifacts from NASA’s Apollo program
Why Even Try if You Have A.I.? Now that machines can think for us, we have to choose wheth...
Recent Posts
Google’s healthcare AI made up a body part — what happens when doctors don’t notice?
Though not in a hospital setting, the “basilar ganglia” is a real error that was…
York Plays 2025: Five cameras, adding up to ~100 hours of footage.
Five cameras, adding up to ~100 hours of footage. I'm almost at the halfway point…
I may have mentioned that I have a daughter who does things. Her next is “To Battle: A Fight Play.” August 1-10.
Tickets for To Battle: A Fight Play
Study finds AI tools made open source software developers 19 percent slower
Coders who used AI self-reported that they worked 20% faster, but an objective study found…
View Comments
Very interesting. Particularly in the memory and retention areas.
"Present-day software must be user-friendly. Indeed, train ticket machines at railway stations should be simple and provide us with a ticket quickly,"
This struck me as particularly funny. Recently I was on business in Charlotte, NC. I had the pleasure to travel uptown using their light rail service for dinner in the city. Great train system, but the self-serve ticket kiosk was so user unfriendly and slow I was amazed .
Finally, If only I could see the faces of some when you introduce the command line...savor the moment.