I Never Would Have Guessed I Would Be Able to Complete a Close Reading

I started my American Literature class by assigning students to listen to 40-minute audio lectures that provided context and walked them through the literary texts we were to discuss in class. As the semester drew on, I had students write podcasts to introduce texts to each other, and by the end of term I was asking students to read scholarly articles in which literary scholars aren’t introducing the texts to beginners, but rather offering evidence-based arguments about the texts.

I’m very glad i took the time to make this video last year.

Students who think literature is about memorizing lists of what the blue curtains symbolize, or who believe that “anything goes” and that there are no wrong answers, can get a gentle correction early in the course, as they make the transition from the techniques that earned them praise in high school (“The character I most identify with is… ” “If I had been in this character’s situation, I would have…” “After the story ends, here is what I think happened to the protagonist.”)

In one of the final assignments for the course, a non-English major in my American Literature class writes:

As we came into the last few portfolios, my classmates and I were forced to rely more and more on each other and the literary texts rather than the podcasts from Dr. Jerz.

I think that even though sometimes this was difficult, and sometimes very boring academic articles made it seem much worse, our class was able to grow as readers and writers because of this.

We were like birds who were thrown out of the nest and forced to fly, and based on our discussions getting deeper and more literary we were able to take off before we hit the ground! 

I never would have guessed that I would be able to complete something like a close reading or actually be able to break down a poem and find the meaning hidden within the words.

Post was last modified on 24 Nov 2016 9:37 am

View Comments

  • I use this wonderful video as the first homework assignment for all my private students. We then apply the skill set to a passage from "Tender is the Night" for our first class. Although most of my students are the equivalent of US high school seniors, they need to work at a freshman year level to pass their university entrance exams. This video sets them up to do just that. They also get a real kick out of the part with the incorrect line!

Share
Published by
Dennis G. Jerz

Recent Posts

First they came… #kristallnacht @nccheshu

First they came… #kristallnacht @nccheshu

3 days ago

Sorry, not sorry. I don’t want such friends.

Back in 2003, shortly after I moved with my wife and two young children to…

5 days ago

In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit. @thepublicpgh

In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit. @thepublicpgh

5 days ago

Despite its impressive output, generative AI doesn’t have a coherent understanding of the world

[A] popular type of generative AI model can provide turn-by-turn driving directions in New York City…

6 days ago