Basically, the [Mars] story is, now get this, a fabrication.

The two researchers, Carol Stoker and Larry Lemke, do think they may have evidence for methane in Mars’ atmosphere. Methane cannot last long without being replenished, and it’s not easy to replenish it. There are non-biological ways (for example, sunlight + C02 plus water, which can be found on Mars), but life is the easiest way we know of. As the story went, they had a secret meeting — with whom, we don’t know — and they were discussing releasing this bombshell to either coincide or predate an article submitted to Nature, a premier scientific journal.

But — and this is the important bit — there was never any meeting! Nor is there a Nature paper. —Phil “The Bad Astronomer” PlaitBasically, the [Mars] story is, now get this, a fabrication. (Bad Astronomy)

I had blogged the original report under Science Fiction. Good work, Phil!

View Comments

  • I think C.S. Lewis said it best. This is just a hunch. I cannot prove this:

    The universe is full of life. But the Earth, due to the fallen nature of man, Adam's sin, is now quarantined. Which is why the nearest inhabitable planet is so far away. God does not want our human BS to pollute the rest of the universe. Good theory, eh?

Share
Published by
Dennis G. Jerz

Recent Posts

Yesterday my stack of unmarked assignments was about 120, so this is not bad.

Nothing in this stack is pressing, but they do include rough drafts of final papers,…

5 hours ago

ai, ai, ai: critical thinking and literacy won’t save you

Here’s the underlying problem. We have an operating image of thought, an understanding of what…

6 hours ago

Representing the Humanities at Accepted Students Day.

Representing the Humanities at Accepted Students Day.

4 days ago

The daughter opens another show. This weekend only.

The daughter opens another show. This weekend only.

4 days ago

How to Disagree Academically: Using Graham’s “Disagreement Hierarchy” to organize a college term paper.

How to Disagree Academically: Using Graham's "Disagreement Hierarchy" to organize a college term paper.

4 days ago

A.I. ‘Completes’ Keith Haring’s Intentionally Unfinished Painting

After learning of his AIDS diagnosis, artist Keith Haring created the work, "Unfinished Painting" (1989),…

5 days ago