Don't Look It Up: The Decline of the Dictionary

“As most people know by now, dictionary makers today merely record how the language is used, not how the language ought to be used. That is, lexicographers are descriptivists, language liberals. People using “disinterested” when they mean “uninterested” does not displease a descriptivist. | A prescriptivist, by contrast, is a language conservative, a person interested in maintaining standards and correctness in language use. To prescriptivists, “disinterested” in the sense of “uninterested” is the result of uneducated people not knowing the distinction between the two words. And if there are enough uneducated people saying “disinterested” (and I’m afraid there are) when they mean “uninterested” or “indifferent,” lexicographers enter the definition into their dictionaries. Indeed, the distinction between these words has all but vanished owing largely to irresponsible writers and boneless lexicographers.” Robert Hartwell FiskeDon’t Look It Up: The Decline of the Dictionary (The Weekly Standard)

View Comments

  • This essay of Fiske's always amuses me, and serves as a humorous reminder that to be a linguist, one needs to study and understand language; to be a grammarian, one simply needs to understand how to belittle someone else. I haven't found a grammarian yet who knows a thing about language.

Share
Published by
Dennis G. Jerz

Recent Posts

A quick Sunday visit to #fortligonier with my history-loving son.

A quick Sunday visit to #fortligonier with my history-loving son.

9 hours ago

The choreographer daughter is doing a thing.

The choreographer daughter is doing a thing.

3 days ago

So I’m starting a thing. Wish me luck. #blender3d #medieval #york #mysteryplay #corpuschristi

So I’m starting a thing. Wish me luck. #blender3d #medieval #york #mysteryplay #corpuschristi

3 days ago

No interior yet. Getting there. Gotta start somewhere. Low-poly background detail for a medieval theater project. #blender3d

No interior yet. Getting there. Gotta start somewhere. Low-poly background detail for a medieval theater…

3 days ago

This is manageable. Far better than some semesters.

This is manageable. Far better than some semesters.

4 days ago

Creating textures for background buildings in a medieval theater simulation project. I can always improve this later. #blender3d

Creating textures for background buildings in a medieval theater simulation project. I can always improve…

5 days ago