High schools no longer prepare most students to express ideas coherently or follow accepted English, let alone carry on serious intellectual work….. The task falls to me — in courses ostensibly about specified topics, not composition — to patch up these leaky vessels…. I hold that a university education ought to include a significant writing component, that student writing deserves substantial professorial comment, that every student can become a better writer with practice, and that this is the last effective chance for them to get practice and feedback. If not us, who? —Max Clio
—Grading on My Nerves (Chronicle)
Similar:
One of my undergrad lit papers. Dot-matrix printed, with hand-written instructor annotatio...
Academia
Sesame Street had a big plot twist in November 1986
My older siblings say they remember our ...
Culture
Ave atque vale
What is a liberal education and what it ...
Academia
I’ve been teaching with this handout for over 25 years, updating it regularly. I just remo...
I first started teaching with this hando...
Academia
The Decline and Fall of the English Major
This essay is yet another reminder of ho...
Academia
A Career-Aligned Major Isn’t Enough
I've taken over teaching the English dep...
Academia



Of course.. back in the good ol’ days, a period in history conjured at will by those who might otherwise have to face reality. Okay, that’s overstating it, but your point is well taken, Will.
One issue is that more people today are going to college simply becuase that’s what they are supposed to do… in the past, college was only for the elite, who came from the best schools. So professors who teach entry-level courses get a wide range of students, including some who simply aren’t ready for college.
“no longer”? Was there really a magical time when they did?